New York25 New York restaurants worth planning around
A wide-ranging New York restaurant shortlist, from defining neighborhood institutions to dining rooms worth booking a trip around.
Explore the guide ↗Compare two confirmed NYC Thanksgiving menus for November 26, 2026: Keens and Tavern on the Green, with adult and child prices and holiday booking advice.
2 picks · By Extro Editorial · Checked 2026-11-12
ajay_suresh / CC BY 4.0 / https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Thanksgiving dinner in New York does not have to mean finding the longest restaurant list. These two Manhattan options have published menus for Thursday, November 26, 2026, and make different starting points for the day: a Midtown steakhouse or a Central Park dining room. This is a focused booking comparison, not a ranking or a claim that tables remain available. Choose your part of Manhattan first Keens is on West 36th Street, useful when your plans are around Herald Square. Tavern on the Green is by West 67th Street and Central Park West. Choose the restaurant that fits the rest of your day rather than trying to turn both into one meal. Allow extra travel time around holiday crowds and make your restaurant confirmation the fixed point in the plan. Compare the complete bill Keens lists $167 per adult and $83 for children under 12. Its holiday menu includes turkey as well as steakhouse alternatives. Ask the restaurant what tax, gratuity and drinks will add before confirming. Tavern on the Green lists a four-course meal at $145 per adult and $65 for children 12 and under. Drinks and tax are extra, and the restaurant states that it adds 20% gratuity. For one adult, $145 plus that gratuity is $174 before tax or drinks; compare the final bill rather than just the headline menu price. Book the holiday, not an ordinary Thursday For Tavern, the location page directs holiday reservations to the restaurant by phone rather than its regular online process. Confirm your seating time, party size, cancellation rules and dietary needs directly. Keens links to its own reservation process and also lists a telephone number. Neither a menu page nor a search result confirms an available table. What if our group has dietary restrictions? Ask about ingredients and preparation before booking. A listed vegetable or fish option does not establish that a full meal meets a particular allergy, vegetarian or accessibility requirement. Is Thanksgiving on November 26 in 2026? Yes. Both restaurants explicitly date their published holiday menus November 26, 2026. Recheck the menu and reservation confirmation close to the meal because dishes and availability can change. Which restaurant is better for children? Both publish a children's price, but the age rules differ: Keens says under 12, while Tavern says 12 and under. Confirm the policy for your child's age with the restaurant. Can we pair dinner with a holiday market? Do not assume every market is open on Thanksgiving. Grand Central's Holiday Fair lists a Thanksgiving closure. Our Midtown market guide explains the separate seasonal stops: https://extroapp.com/guides/midtown-holiday-markets-2026-bryant-park-grand-central. For a broader food shortlist beyond this holiday meal, see https://extroapp.com/guides/best-restaurants-new-york.
Image: ajay_suresh / CC BY 4.0 / https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Choose this West 36th Street steakhouse for a holiday dinner with turkey and alternatives such as its mutton chop. The dated 2026 menu lists $167 per adult and $83 for children under 12. Confirm the complete bill, dietary requirements and seating availability through keens.com or 212-947-3636.
Visit website ↗Choose the Central Park dining room for a four-course Thanksgiving meal. The restaurant lists November 26 service from 11am–10pm, $145 per adult and $65 for children 12 and under; beverages and tax are extra, with 20% gratuity added. Call 212-877-8684 for holiday reservations and confirm the current cancellation policy.
Visit website ↗
New YorkA wide-ranging New York restaurant shortlist, from defining neighborhood institutions to dining rooms worth booking a trip around.
Explore the guide ↗
New YorkCocktail destinations, music rooms, neighborhood bars and dressed-up classics for different versions of a New York night.
Explore the guide ↗
New YorkMuseums, city walks, performances, parks and skyline experiences that can anchor a first trip or refresh a return visit.
Explore the guide ↗