New York / Food & drink

10 NYC comfort-food spots worth saving, from bagels to lobster rolls

Ten New York food stops for pastrami, bagels, burgers, Indian-inspired tacos, pizza and lobster rolls, with exact branches and useful route notes.

10 picks · By Extro editorial · Checked 2026-11-05

Katz’s Delicatessen / official website

A food-focused New York trip works better when the recommendations fit your day. These ten stops cover different appetites and neighborhoods: a deli lunch on the Lower East Side, bagels in Midtown, burgers near the East Village, and dedicated outings to Queens or southern Brooklyn. Pick a few that fit your route. This is a citywide save-list, not a ten-meal walking tour. The candidate venues come from our creator recommendation repository. We then check current official branch information and write our own planning notes. The display order balances practical routes and different kinds of meals; it is an editorial shortlist, not a scientific taste ranking or a claim of firsthand visits. Menus and service arrangements change, so verify your selected dish and branch directly. How to use the list For a compact downtown day, choose one East Village or Union Square meal and leave space for other plans. Give Red Hook, Bayside or Knapp Street a separate travel window. If your priority is a particular item featured in a video, check today's menu first rather than assuming the old special is permanent. Questions before you go Are all ten near one another? No. This guide covers Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens, and names the exact branch for each. Does a guide entry reserve a table? No. Use the restaurant's own reservation or ordering links to confirm service. Is this a budget ranking? No. Prices and portion sizes vary. Check the current menu and choose a meal that suits your budget. Can every place accommodate dietary restrictions? Ask the selected restaurant about ingredients and preparation; a place's inclusion here is not an allergy or dietary certification. For a broader dinner shortlist, explore Extro's New York restaurant guide. Our bar guide can help you choose a separate evening stop without overpacking the food itinerary.

01
Katz’s Delicatessen — Lower East Side
205 East Houston Street, ManhattanBest for a substantial deli lunch
Image: Katz’s Delicatessen / official website
Make pastrami the anchor of a Lower East Side meal rather than a snack you rush between reservations. Use the original Houston Street location at Ludlow Street, and check the current restaurant hours before choosing a late visit. The deli's size and counter-service rhythm are part of the experience; allow room for a queue. This is a food stop to enjoy on its own, not the first of ten meals you must squeeze into one day.
Visit website ↗
02
Fedoroff’s Roast Pork — Williamsburg
178 North 10th Street, BrooklynBest for a Philadelphia-style sandwich in Brooklyn
Image: Fedoroff’s Roast Pork / official website
Head to North 10th Street when your Williamsburg plans call for a filling sandwich. The business focuses on Philadelphia-style roast pork, cheesesteaks and hoagies, so choose it for that specific craving rather than expecting a broad sit-down restaurant menu. Its official site lists daily service and a direct contact address. Check the ordering menu for availability before traveling for one particular sandwich; a dish appearing in a creator's older post is not a guarantee it is available today.
Visit website ↗
03
Utopia Bagels — Midtown
120 East 34th Street, ManhattanBest for a bagel breakfast before a Midtown day
Image: Utopia Bagels / official website
Use the East 34th Street branch for a Midtown breakfast without making a separate trip to the original Queens shop. The official branch page currently lists daily service from 6 AM to 4 PM. Pick the bagel and filling that suit your appetite, and leave time for busy morning periods. Utopia operates several city locations, so check that your pickup order and navigation both say Midtown; a generic brand search can send you to another borough.
Visit website ↗
04
SMASHED NYC — East Village
94 Third Avenue, ManhattanBest for a crisp-edged burger near the East Village
Image: SMASHED NYC / official website
Choose Third Avenue for an in-person burger stop near the East Village. The current official site lists burgers, chicken sandwiches and sides, with branch-specific ordering links. Check the selected restaurant before relying on late service. The brand's West Village entry is temporarily marked delivery-only on its homepage, so this guide deliberately uses the East Village branch. Do not substitute a delivery kitchen for a dining-room recommendation or assume every branch has the same breakfast service.
Visit website ↗
05
Taco Mahal — West Village
73 Seventh Avenue South, ManhattanBest for an Indian-flavor lunch on a Village walk
Image: Taco Mahal / official website
Pick the Seventh Avenue South location when you want Indian-inspired tacos during a West Village walk. The branch sits between Barrow and Bleecker Streets and is accessible from Christopher Street or West 4th Street subway stops. Check the current menu to choose your base and filling rather than assuming one creator's order is the only worthwhile choice. The business now lists several Manhattan branches; keep the West Village address selected when ordering or planning your route.
Visit website ↗
06
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza — East Village
321 East 14th Street, ManhattanBest for a substantial slice around an East Village evening
Image: Artichoke Basille’s Pizza / official website
Use the current East 14th Street address for the East Village branch. Artichoke is a useful choice when a hearty slice fits better than a full table-service meal, but check the display and menu before committing to a particular topping. The official branch page lists late daily service; recheck on the day rather than treating that as a promise of admission or a fixed queue. This is the 321 East 14th Street location, not an older address you may see in archive photos.
Visit website ↗
07
Unregular Pizza — Union Square
135 Fourth Avenue, ManhattanBest for a pizza stop near Union Square
Image: Unregular Pizza / official website
Use the Fourth Avenue shop when you want pizza close to Union Square's transit connections. Its official directory separates this branch from Essex Market and lists different closing times, so check the right location before ordering. Build the stop into an existing downtown route rather than crossing the city for several slices at once. A menu-specific recommendation should follow a current menu check; the source repository's enthusiasm is a starting point, not a claim that every old special is still offered.
Visit website ↗
08
Red Hook Lobster Pound — Red Hook
284 Van Brunt Street, BrooklynBest for a seafood meal with a Red Hook afternoon
Image: Red Hook Lobster Pound / official website
Make this the destination when you want a lobster-focused meal and enough time to enjoy Red Hook. The flagship lists indoor and outdoor dining, takeout and reservations through Resy. Its current page shows noon to 9 PM service, with last seating at 8:30 PM. Plan transport rather than assuming a subway exit is outside the door: the restaurant's own FAQ points visitors toward the Red Hook ferry landing and local bus connections. Seasonal beach and market concessions are separate locations.
Visit website ↗
09
Krave It — Bayside
40-15 Bell Boulevard, QueensBest for an inventive pizza-and-sandwich detour in Queens
Image: Krave It / official website
Choose Bayside when a Queens food outing is the point of the day. The official location directory lists Bell Boulevard alongside separate Astoria and Huntington branches. Check the live ordering menu for the pizza or sandwich that interests you, because the more elaborate specials in social videos may change. This is a substantial detour from the Manhattan entries, so give it its own time rather than describing all ten places as one easy walking route. Confirm branch hours directly before setting off.
Visit website ↗
10
Knapp Street Pizza
2157 Knapp Street, BrooklynBest for a neighborhood pizza stop in southern Brooklyn
Image: Knapp Street Pizza / official website
Save the Knapp Street shop for a southern Brooklyn day rather than forcing it into a short Manhattan visit. Its official site identifies 2157 Knapp Street and provides menu and ordering controls. Use those for today's options, especially when a creator post highlights a particular pizza or garlic-knot combination. A neighborhood pizza meal can be the whole plan; leave enough travel time and check the actual service hours before going. Do not confuse this address with other businesses using a similar Knapp name.
Visit website ↗